Multicenter prospective study of concordance between embryonic cell-free DNA and trophectoderm biopsies from 1301 human blastocysts

Background: The recent identification of embryonic cell-free DNA in spent blastocyst media has opened a new era of possibilities for noninvasive embryo aneuploidy testing in assisted reproductive technologies. Yet, previous studies assessing a limited number of embryos reported variable concordance between embryonic cell-free DNA and trophectoderm biopsies, thus questioning the validity of this approach. Objective: This study aimed to evaluate the concordance and reproducibility of testing embryonic cell-free DNA vs trophectoderm DNA obtained from the same embryo in a large sample of human blastocysts and to assess the contribution of the inner cell mass and trophectoderm to embryonic cell-free DNA released to the culture media. Study design: This is an interim analysis of a prospective, observational study among 8 in vitro fertilization centers in 4 continents to assess consistency between noninvasive embryo aneuploidy testing of embryonic cell-free DNA and conventional trophectoderm biopsy. The analysis included 1301 day-6/7 blastocysts obtained in 406 in vitro fertilization cycles from 371 patients aged 20-44 years undergoing preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy. Fresh oocytes underwent intracytoplasmic sperm injection or in vitro fertilization. No previous assisted hatching or vitrification was allowed before media collection. Individual spent blastocyst medium was collected from embryos cultured at least 40 hours from day 4. After media collection, conventional preimplantation genetic testing for aneuploidy, comprising trophectoderm biopsy and blastocyst vitrification, was performed. Embryonic cell-free DNA was analyzed blindly after embryo transfer. Inner cell mass and trophectoderm biopsies were also performed in a subset of 81 aneuploid blastocysts donated for research. Results: Embryonic cell-free DNA analyses were 78.2% (866/1108) concordant with the corresponding trophectoderm biopsies. No significant differences were detected among centers ranging from 72.5% to 86.3%. Concordance rates exceeded 86% when all defined steps in the culture laboratory were controlled to minimize the impact of maternal and operator contamination. Sensitivity per center ranged from 76.5% to 91.3% and specificity from 64.7% to 93.3%. The false-negative rate was 8.3% (92/1108), and false-positive rate was 12.4% (137/1108). The 2 fertilization techniques provided similar sensitivity (80.9% vs 87.9%) and specificity (78.6% vs 69.9%). Multivariate analysis did not reveal any bias from patient clinical background, ovarian stimulation protocols, culture conditions, or embryo quality on testing accuracy of concordance. Moreover, concordances of embryonic cell-free DNA with trophectoderm and inner cell mass suggest that the embryonic cell-free DNA originates from both compartments of the human embryo. Conclusion: Noninvasive analysis of embryonic cell-free DNA in spent blastocyst culture media demonstrates high concordance with trophectoderm biopsy results in this large multicenter series. A noninvasive approach for prioritizing embryo euploidy offers important advantages such as avoiding invasive embryo biopsy and decreased cost, potentially increasing accessibility for a wider patient population.