This paper reframes the transition from sustainable to regenerative cultural tourism as a governance challenge rather than a technical one. Drawing on business-ecosystem theory, the polycentric governance tradition associated with Ostrom and recent advances in the regenerative-tourism literature, the paper develops the APDG-HARMONY framework as a diagnostic instrument for reading destination complexity. The framework is structured along four substantive dimensions (Actors, Processes, Dynamics, Governance) and one cross-cutting evaluative dimension (Harmony alignment), each operationalised through sub-dimensions, sample indicators and evidence sources. A mixed-methods conceptual-applied design is adopted: theoretical synthesis is followed by an embedded single-case analysis of the SPIDIT project, an explicitly polycentric inter-municipal experiment in the Marche region of central Italy involving seven municipalities of the Riviera and Borghi del Piceno area. The case is treated as an exploratory laboratory and proof of concept rather than as a validation of regenerative outcomes, since the project is still in formation. The diagnosis surfaces three governance priorities: substantive co-decision rights between coastal and hinterland actors, integrated monitoring across the two subsystems, and the embedding of regenerative incentives in incumbent coastal hospitality operators' business models. The paper contributes to the debate on post-sustainability cultural tourism governance by offering an operationalisable instrument that bridges conceptual ambition and field practice. Limitations include the single-case design, the case's ongoing nature, and the inherently evaluative nature of the alignment assessment, which the framework treats as a feature rather than a bug.

From Aggregation to Regeneration: A Polycentric Ecosystem Framework for Cultural Tourism Destinations

Guido Capanna Piscè
;
Luca Giraldi
2026

Abstract

This paper reframes the transition from sustainable to regenerative cultural tourism as a governance challenge rather than a technical one. Drawing on business-ecosystem theory, the polycentric governance tradition associated with Ostrom and recent advances in the regenerative-tourism literature, the paper develops the APDG-HARMONY framework as a diagnostic instrument for reading destination complexity. The framework is structured along four substantive dimensions (Actors, Processes, Dynamics, Governance) and one cross-cutting evaluative dimension (Harmony alignment), each operationalised through sub-dimensions, sample indicators and evidence sources. A mixed-methods conceptual-applied design is adopted: theoretical synthesis is followed by an embedded single-case analysis of the SPIDIT project, an explicitly polycentric inter-municipal experiment in the Marche region of central Italy involving seven municipalities of the Riviera and Borghi del Piceno area. The case is treated as an exploratory laboratory and proof of concept rather than as a validation of regenerative outcomes, since the project is still in formation. The diagnosis surfaces three governance priorities: substantive co-decision rights between coastal and hinterland actors, integrated monitoring across the two subsystems, and the embedding of regenerative incentives in incumbent coastal hospitality operators' business models. The paper contributes to the debate on post-sustainability cultural tourism governance by offering an operationalisable instrument that bridges conceptual ambition and field practice. Limitations include the single-case design, the case's ongoing nature, and the inherently evaluative nature of the alignment assessment, which the framework treats as a feature rather than a bug.
File in questo prodotto:
Non ci sono file associati a questo prodotto.

I documenti in IRIS sono protetti da copyright e tutti i diritti sono riservati, salvo diversa indicazione.

Utilizza questo identificativo per citare o creare un link a questo documento: https://hdl.handle.net/11576/2784892
Citazioni
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.pmc??? ND
  • Scopus ND
  • ???jsp.display-item.citation.isi??? ND
social impact